Son had child sex image to try to trap father, court hears

The images depicted young females aged between five and 16 years old in explicit positions, with a few images showing children of about 12 years of age engaged in sexual activity with an adult.
Son had child sex image to try to trap father, court hears

Carlow Courthouse

A MAN who discovered that his father had been sharing fantasies with a woman of abusing named children deliberately sent his father images of child sexual abuse in a bid to entrap him.

Padraig Fahy (35) was caught by gardaí in June 2019 after the uploading of a single image of child abuse material was traced back to him. He had used a Facebook account and an email address under a false name to send the images to his father.

This led to a warrant being secured to search Mr Fahy’s home, during which a computer and two phones were seized. Forensic analysis of these devices led to the discovery of over 2,250 images.

Mr Fahy of Academy Court, Carlow pleaded guilty at Carlow Circuit Criminal Court last week to one count of possession of child sexual abuse images on 10 January 2020. He further pleaded guilty to the offence of distributing child sexually explicit material on 26 August 2018 at his home address after he emailed explicit images on four separate occasions.

Mr Fahy has no previous convictions and has not come to garda attention since.

Det Garda Pat Prendergast told Brian O’Shea BL, prosecuting, that Mr Fahy had made admissions and acknowledged that he had downloaded and knowingly possessed images of child abuse material. The images depicted young females aged between five and 16 years old in explicit positions, with a few images showing children of about 12 years of age engaged in sexual activity with an adult.

Det Garda Prendergast agreed with Éamonn O’Moore BL, defending, that Mr Fahy had told gardaí he had sent the images to his father because he was “trying to catch him”.

Mr Fahy said he had discovered that his father was having an affair with a woman and he had found conversations between his father and this woman involving discussions of their fantasies about sexually abusing named children.

Det Garda Prendergast confirmed to the court that it was “a bizarre scenario”, but gardaí thoroughly investigated Mr Fahy’s claims and found them to be valid. He said Mr Fahy’s father had died two weeks before gardaí searched the accused’s property.

He said gardaí were continuing to investigate the woman who was conversing with Mr Fahy’s father.

Det Garda Prendergast agreed with Mr O’Moore that Mr Fahy had “genuine concerns” that the children named in these conversations would be interfered with.

Mr O’Moore said his client was previously employed in IT in technical support but had lost his job after his first appearance in the circuit court was published in the local newspaper. He said Mr Fahy had an unfortunate childhood and that he began to view images of the sexual abuse of children after he “stumbled across this type of material” previously from his father.

Counsel acknowledged this was “no justification” for Mr Fahy’s behaviour and that “there is a problem that has to be addressed”.

He said his motive in relation to the distribution charge was to entrap his father because he was concerned that these children would be sexually abused. Mr O’Moore added that his client was willing to get treatment and had been in contact with One In Four in relation to treatment for sexual offenders.

Sentencing Mr Fahy, Mr Justice Keenan Johnson said Mr Fahy’s father had exchanged fantasies about abusing specific children and that the accused had “considerable concerns” about this and had decided to distribute images to his father in an attempt to catch him. He said Mr Fahy should have reported his concerns to the gardaí.

“The internet is a cesspool with appalling images of young children being abused. These are all young victims, probably in countries far away, exploited and abused by sinister forces,” Mr Justice Johnson said.

He added that sometimes the people who run these sites set them up in an attempt to generate money and that anyone who pays for these images and generally distributes them has to be treated seriously by the courts.

Justice Johnson said the behaviour was “so objectionable” that the court was obliged, in terms of punishment and deterrence, to deal with these cases in a serious way. He accepted the evidence that Mr Fahy also had a large number of images himself, which, he said, he had clearly downloaded “following observations of his own father’s behaviours”.

Mr Justice Johnson said he was satisfied that the distribution charge related to Mr Fahy’s attempt to entrap his father, but again commented that the “the proper authority to investigate these things was the gardaí”.

He accepted that Mr Fahy’s plea of guilty had saved the cost of a trial to the state, that he had no previous convictions and had not come to the “adverse attention” of the gardaí. Mr Justice Johnson said that he was also satisfied that the evidence before the court led him to conclude that the defendant was at a low risk of reoffending and that the interests of society would be best served by Mr Fahy completing rehabilitation.

He imposed a sentence of two years for the possession of the images and a concurrent term of six months for the distribution charge. The two-year sentence was suspended in full on condition that Mr Fahy keep the peace and be of good behaviour for five years, submit himself to the supervision of the probation service for 12 months and complete rehabilitation with One In Four, or its equivalent, within two years, to the satisfaction of the probation service.

Mr Justice Johnson also ordered that the €5,000 that Mr Fahy had in court be donated to a local branch of Barnardos.

He said this money was “as a degree of restitution” and was “not to buy your way out of court – that is never going to happen”. He said this would put a considerable burden on Mr Fahy and also benefit a charity.

Funded by the Court Reporting Scheme

More in this section