Former Air Corps officer from Kildare claims he was framed for assault
Nile Donohoe of Watergrange, Kildare, had denied assaulting his commanding officer and using insulting language towards him during an altercation at Casement Aerodrome, Baldonnel in August 2007
A FORMER Air Corps Commandant from Kildare is arguing that his conviction for assaulting a lieutenant colonel 19 years ago was a miscarriage of justice, claiming that he was framed by senior officers "who had the knife into him" before his trial.
Nile Donohoe of Watergrange, Kildare, had denied assaulting his commanding officer and using insulting language towards him during an altercation at Casement Aerodrome, Baldonnel on 10 August 2007.
The assault was by way of poking the shirt of Lt Col John Maloney with his finger and calling him "a piece of shit".
Having been found guilty by a board of Defence Force members, Mr Donohoe was fined 10 days' pay and sentenced to a reduction to the fourth point of the pay scale for the rank of Commandant by a military judge at McKee Barracks on 12 June 2015.
The Court of Appeal dismissed his attempt to overturn that verdict in March 2017 and leave to appeal to the Supreme Court was refused in March 2020.
He now seeks to adduce evidence of new or newly discovered facts in support of his appeal.
He alleges that following the incident in August 2007, Lt Col Maloney and another officer secretly summoned an army captain to a meeting during which they "pressurised her" to make an improperly founded complaint against Mr Donohoe.
The appellant maintains senior officers framed him and he sought leave to adduce the affidavit of the former captain and a flight sergeant.
At the Court of Appeal on Thursday, counsel for Mr Donohoe, Eanna Mulloy SC said that these newly discovered facts prove an animus between Mr Donohoe and his superiors.
He said that the former captain, who was then reporting to Mr Donohoe, was "leaned on" and encouraged to make her complaint.
Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy responded that while Mr Donohoe had used the word "pressurised", the former captain had said she had a meeting with two different people and then brought her complaint, but nowhere in her affidavit had she said she was "pressurised".
Mr Mulloy replied that while she did not say it was a false complaint, she had stated in her affidavit that but for the approaches and reapproaches made to her, she may not have made the complaint.
"They prompted her to make a complaint, but that's very far removed from pressurised," remarked Ms Justice Kennedy.
Mr Justice Charles Meenan said that nothing was being submitted to challenge the evidence given against the appellant.
He said that even if both witnesses said that senior officers had been out to get Mr Donohoe, unless his legal team challenged the evidence, there were no new facts.
Mr Mulloy said there had been no victim impact report whatsoever, so this was an indicative fact that there never was any assault.
"The military authorities had the knife into him before this trial," said Mr Mulloy.
In response, the director of military prosecutions said that Mr Donohoe is "seeking to challenge his conviction largely focusing on issues of military criminal procedure and alleged prosecutorial bias, rather than any identifiable unfairness in the substance of the trial itself or want of evidence to support the conviction".
It was submitted that no attempt was made to connect "the entirely unfocused and generalised complaints and grievances" to Mr Donohoe's actual trial. It was also submitted that the alleged new facts relied on in the two affidavits do not relate to the altercation of 10 August 2007, but to an entirely separate incident in which Donohoe was charged with the assault of a lieutenant.
Counsel for the director of military prosecutions, Remy Farrell SC, said it was a novelty to see such an application being advanced without any reference to the transcript of the trial.
He said that the former captain was not now saying that she made a false complaint, merely that she was encouraged to make the complaint.
He said it was extraordinary that no attempt was being made by the appellant to link the affidavit of the captain to his original trial, other than to suggest "an animus in a general way".
Mr Farrell said that no attempt had been made to identify when this information came to Mr Donohoe's attention, how it is new evidence, nor how it would be deployed in a trial.
He added that clearly these were not newly discovered facts.
Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy, presiding over the three-judge court, said that judgment in the case will be reserved to a later date.
