'Don’t cry wolf' warns Kildare judge as wife withdraws assault charge
Photo for illustrative purposes only
A JUDGE brought a parable to court to highlight wasting garda time after a victim of alleged domestic assault wanted to have the charge struck out.
The case was heard behind the closed doors of Naas District Court as is protocol in matters domestic, as the man was charged with both the assault in December, and a subsequent breach of a safety order at the home address in Newbridge.
“Peace has broken out?” Judge Desmond Zaidan assumed.
“(Named woman) wants the charge withdrawn,” said her solicitor, Tim Kennelly.
“That’s a matter for the state,” the judge warned her that it is not necessarily her choice.
“There’s no independent witness,” Inspector Bobby Feery said.
“It’s a case of ‘He says, she says’,” he added, so the judge consented.
“Do you appreciate the amount of time, garda time, that went into trying to help you from your husband’s behaviour?” asked the judge.
“Just to inform (named woman), we’ll always be there for you,”reassured Inspector Feery.
“I don’t subscribe to that,” said the judge.
“Have you heard the parable about the shepherd who always called ‘wolf’?
“Well, it doesn’t work like that.
“But you’re the one who forgave him, so I won’t criticise you.
“But you sir,” he said pointing at the husband, “if you come before me again, I’ll remand you in custody”.
“He’s off the drink,” offered Mr Kennelly.
“Is he behaving himself?” asked the judge cautiously.
“We just got back from holiday together,” said the wife.
“And he’s staying off the drink?” asked the judge.
“He was on the beach sunning himself!” remarked Mr Kennelly.
“OK. I will strike out (the remaining charge),” concluded the judge.
